Antique Imitation of Chinese Porcelain – A Case Study

Qing Dynasty Covered Urn from Midwest Auction Galleries
Qing Dynasty Covered Urn from Midwest Auction Galleries

It is a tradition in Chinese culture that artisans of later generations imitate earlier works as part of the learning process. In Chinese, “Lao Fang” means imitation made before 1911 when Republic of China was founded, and “Min Guo Fang” are those made during the regime of the Chinese Nationalist Party. These are NOT, by any standard, forgeries but could confuse collectors by their hi fidelity and excellent  craftsmanship.

A curious case came today at Midwest Auction Galleries, when the sale included a Qing Dynasty urn with Ming Dynasty mark. Lot 228 features a fairly large urn with Chinese character “double happiness”. The catalog says:

Possibly from the Jiaqing Period. Bears the 4 character mark in underglaze blue: “Cheng Hua Nian Zhi” which translates as “Made in Cheng Hua.” Very large measuring 17″ H x 10″ Dia. Private collection, Metamora, Michigan

Jiaqing ruled China from 1796 to 1820. It is generally consented that Qing Dynasty began to decline from his regime. The White Lotus Rebellion and the rampant opium were two causes that led to the falling of the empire. But the artisanship overall was kept at fairly high level, if not as great as that of his father Qianlong period.

The mark of the bottom of the urn says “Made In Cheng Hua”, which leads to an emperor of Ming Dynasty who ruled China in the second half of the 15th century. There is a good reason that porcelain artisans of later period seeks inspiration from works from Chenghua because the achievement of porcelain making with respect to quality, style and innovation was not rivaled until Yongzheng period, which was 150 years later. “Ming Kan Cheng Hua, Qing Kan Yong Zheng” was one of the famous old sayings of collecting procelain. It means the best Ming porcelain appears in Chenghua period while Yongzheng period produced the most consummate works in Qing Dynasty.

Detail of a porcelain made in Chenghua period, showing Shuang Gou style
Detail of a porcelain made in Chenghua period, showing Shuang Gou technique

Ink blue porcelain came to a turning point in Chenghua period.

First the color changed from strong and exuberant of earlier period to restraint and paler. The blue material comes from Raozhou of Jiangxi province, which tends to be dainty in color. From this perspective, this one surely showcases an exquisite subtle blue evenly painted.

Secondly, the painting style of the ink blue porcelain also changed to be more feeble and graceful. In particular, “shuang gou” was used. Shuang gou or double-stroke is a term not as a specific calligraphy style, but as a technique used for both writing and painting. It basically means to to hollow out words or objects such that each stroke or gesture is represented by two strokes or gestures. (You may think of wood engraving.) The outlined strokes are often in darker blue color while inside the outline is painted in a textureless light blue.

Some collectors called such a style consummate naivity because children often draw the outlines first and then color objects in a flattening way.

Early scholars was puzzled that there were no big porcelainware from Chenghua period. Such a statement has been proved wrong because certain large (some unfortunately broken) works have been found recently.  The scarcity of Chenhua porcelain has made the generalization of Chenghua period almost impossible because of the meager number of samples available.

The mark at the bottom betrayed the maker. The official kiln in Chenghua period had special personels whose job was to write the marks, which are also six-character mark ” Da Ming Cheng Hua Nian Zhi”, which means “Made in Chenghua period, Ming Dynasty”. None of the four-character-marked porcelain has been attributed to be authentic period works. In fact, because probably all marks were written by the same person, the particularity of these six characters has been summarized as one of the criteria for authentication.

The mark on the imitation porcelain made in Qing Dynasty
The mark on the imitation porcelain made in Qing Dynasty, only four characters
Official Mark - Six-character
Official Mark: Six characters

Well, although it is a little bit disappointing to know that this lot is not a real Chenghua masterpiece, it is still desirable and surely beautiful to behold. In fact, I would be more conservative to comment if it had a six-character mark, because modern forgery uses all these tricks  to confuse collectors while the incentive to forge a late imitation work is not great enough. A Chenghua porcelain was sold at Sotheby’s HongKong a few days ago for 36 million HK dollars, while a Jiaqing imitation work can be found regularly in Chinese antique markets.  Since I am not anywhere near the position to obtain an authentic Chenghua porcelain, I would not be tempted if there were one with an affordable price tag.

36 milllion HK dollars, still a bargain based on the presale estimation at Sotheby's
36 milllion HK dollars, still a bargain based on the presale estimation at Sotheby's

Below is the Chuanhua porcelain that made the news at Sotheby’s.

If you are interested in learning more about those four-character “Chenghua” mark from the Qing Dynasty and want to know which mark leads to which Qing emperor period, this is the page you should refer to. You don’t have to read Chinese, just focus on the shape of the character, and be critical and firm on attribution, you will find it is not that hard.

9 comments

Hi all, I wanted to tell you that I have an antique piece of four Chinese characters and wanted to know if it is a valuable piece?, If you need photos I can send some, I am using a translator so sorry for the inconvenience …
Alan Pretzsch from Argentina

Dear Sir,
A mark on a Chinese porcelain piece does not mean much. One has to see the piece and judge, in what period it belongs. This is done based on its shape, decoration, glaze, and other characteristics. If it has a mark, it can then be decided, if the mark corresponds to the period when the piece was made.
Best regards,
Werner Troesch
Manila

hi i have a six character mark of chenghua blue and white with lion motif in center and the white back ground has ivory rings true characteristics of chenghuas work tring to find its worth so many people say they know so mush on this but no anwsers to me sure would like one

Hi there. I have this bronze incent burner with markings under the piece that marks Xuan de nian zhi 1423-1435 years. Can you help me find out if this is real or fake please.

Hi, I have two vases from an old relative who left me these in her will about 20 years ago. I came across them when I was clearing my loft space out. I had completely forgotten them. I have done a little research on line and it has left my confessed as both vases display all the marks of being real. I.e.. rust spots, creaking with yellowish colour, reddish brown where the porcelain stops etc etc. However, with all this I have only 4 marks on the bottom of each vase. I think it’s from The chenghau period?! Could it be real?

Leave a Reply

*