Frederick William MacMonnies and His Works in Brooklyn

Horse Tamer, courtesy to Wallyg at Flickr Frederick William MacMonnies
Horse Tamer, courtesy to Wally at Flickr

There is nothing more pleasant than sitting in the living room with a cup of wine at night and watching the liveness at the entrance of Prospect Park: people running, walking, biking, with dogs, with strollers, or with books fresh out of the library. No matter what they are doing, people naturally slow down. As if suddenly struck by the light, they would look up: There, divided by the busy traffic flow, stands the Soldiers’ and Sailor’s Memorial Arch by Mckim, Mead, and White.

The night view of the Grand Army Plaza is gorgeous. The Arch has always been dimly illuminated in purple light, which plays down the triumphant gesture of Lady Columbia riding a chariot. Although as if all traffic merges in front of the arc, they immediately skew away at different angles, leaving the park in peace and solitude.

It was not long ago that I began to get interested in Frederick William MacMonnies. At a beautiful house in Boerum Hill, the owner, who deals and collects antiques in his life, pointed out a bronze statue in the middle of his living room. “That’s by MacMonnies, who also made the statues at the Grand Army Plaza.” I cannot remember it clearly although, in my vague impression, it resembles a dancing bacchante, I must have seen the monumental statues in the plaza hundreds of times.

Soldiers and Sailors' Memorial Arch
Soldiers and Sailors’ Memorial Arch

MacMonnies was a Brooklynite and Brooklyn offered him the best spot for showing his talent. Although the memorial arch itself is very Parisian, Quadriga, the group statues of the arch by MacMonnies, is American. The Spirit of the Army and The Spirit of the Navy flanked on each side both have compact compositions as if they narrate all aspects of the Civil War. Soldiers and officials are depicted in different layers and depths. Above all this turbulence, Lady Columbia, an allegorical figure of the United States, leads the victory with winged angles playing trumpet upon her arrival.

The south end of the park entrance, which faces the beginning of Ocean Pkwy, features a pair of statues by MacMonnies atop granite pedestals by Stanford White. It was exhibited at the Paris Exposition in 1900 and at the Pan-American Exposition in Buffalo the next year with the title “The Triumph of Mind Over Bruce Forte”. Its highly dramatic effect, exultant mood, and dynamic arrangement differ from that of his mentor August Saint-Gaudens who imbued his works with more sensibility and humanity. The somber mood at the sculpture “54th Massachusetts Volunteer Infantry” by Saint-Gaudens completed only a few years ago disintegrates in the high spirit of the Gilded Age. The optimistic fortissimo permeated throughout the end of the 19th century in New York City is evidently shown here: The tamer’s unyielding physicality and mentality are the manifestations of American power in the age of the Industrial Revolution.

General Henry Warner Slocum , courtesy to wallyg on Frickr
General Henry Warner Slocum, courtesy to Wally on Flickr

Just as I thought I had seen them all, a few days ago at a Brooklyn Fleamarket, I saw an old postcard of the statue of General Henry Warner Slocum. I didn’t know who he was although I almost passed by him every day with the grinding wind at the plaza. The statue in the postcard was shown at a different place. But it is nice to move another work by Macmonnies into the plaza. The inclusion of General Slocum is appropriate because he was an important figure in the Civil War but also served as the Commissioner of Public Works in Brooklyn. Sanford White’s pedestal is adorned with a relief eagle on the front and four medallions, two on each side. Strangely the medallions are Medusa, but probably Macmonnies was not responsible for decorating the pedestal. On the Memorial Day of 1905, Theodore Roosevelt unveiled the monument. Macmonnies would probably be there. Not too far away from the corner of Eastern Pkwy and Bedford Ave where the monument was originally located, the boathouse was completed in the lakewater of the lake inside the park in the vein of Beaux-Arts style. By then, the grandeur and classism of architecture and sculpture, which dominate the area where I am now living, came full-fledged: It looks European but bigger, stronger, and louder.

 


Portland Art Events Calendar

Discover more from Urban Art & Antiques

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Responses

  1. War and Crime — Honor Roll Monument at Prospect Park | Urban Art and Antiques Avatar

    […] were just walking through the park, a trip I called from Quadriga to Horse Tamer since Macmonnie’s statues are so dominating and powerful. Then we decided to walk along the […]

    Like

  2. The Vanishing Points — The Transformation of Grand Army Plaza Through Viewing Vintage Postcards | Urban Art and Antiques Avatar

    […] group statues of “The Spirit of the Army” and “The Spirit of the Navy” by MacMonnie was not mounted. Geo always comments on a desire for the monument to be in a simpler form. The […]

    Like

  3. New American Wing at Met | Urban Art and Antiques Avatar

    […] video, the sculptures in the American Wing will take a prominent new look. Some of the works by Frederick William Macmonnie, Daniel Chester French and August Saint-Gauden are introduced in this video clip. Unfortunately, […]

    Like

  4. Auction Preview - At Bonhams and Doyle | Urban Art and Antiques Avatar

    […] four statues by Frederic William Macmonnies were scattered around, Geo was more attracted by Paul Howard Manship’s “Morning and […]

    Like

  5. Augustus Saint-Gaudens at Met | Urban Art and Antiques Avatar

    […] from Grand Army Plaza, Brooklyn where the thematic monuments are tour de force of  Frederick William Macmonnie, a protege of Saint-Gardens, Geo and I were both touched by the tender personality in the statues […]

    Like

  6. Bacchante « Brooklyn Graphite Avatar

    […] a nice little trilogy of the theme. Thankfully it seems the work of Fredrick William MacMonnies is all over Brooklyn. It’s displayed on the Grand Army Plaza arch and in a few parks around the city. […]

    Like

  7. Paul McMonnies Avatar

    As a descendant it is so nice to see that “Uncle Fred”s work is so popular 🙂

    I was lucky enough to visit America in 1998 and travelled all around Brooklyn and New York to see Fred’s work (I’ve also seen some of his work in Washington and Princeton) – would love to come back again some time soon to do the same tour again with my son !

    Like

Leave a comment

Antiques Mysteries and Great Paintings from Urban Art Antiques | Listen Notes